International FootballRefereeing storm after the Madrid derby: Committee confirms string of errors in Atlético's favour, VAR exposed at its blind spot
International Football
Refereeing storm after the Madrid derby: Committee confirms string of errors in Atlético's favour, VAR exposed at its blind spot
Nguồn: Goal.com – The referees' committee sets off a storm after the derby (ngày xuất bản không xác định) | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn Core answer: Ủy ban Kỹ thuật Trọng tài Tây Ban Nha xác nhận trọng tài Ortiz Arias mắc ba sai sót có lợi cho Atletico Madrid trong trận derby, gồm bỏ qua thẻ đỏ cho Kang-in Lee và không truất quyền thi đấu Romero. Key facts: - Kang-in Lee phạm lỗi nguy hiểm với Valverde, không bị phạt thẻ. - Romero phạm lỗi với Bellingham trong vòng cấm, không bị đuổi. - Bellingham nhận thẻ vàng nhầm người, VAR đã sửa. - Huijsen bị đuổi đúng vì kéo áo Giuliano Simeone. - VAR can thiệp 2 lần, bỏ qua 1 tình huống nghiêm trọng. Related Q&A: - Hỏi: VAR có xem lại pha của Kang-in Lee không? Đáp: Không, tổ VAR không can thiệp. - Hỏi: Romero có bị phạt không? Đáp: Không, dù Ủy ban xác định phạm lỗi với Bellingham. - Hỏi: Huijsen có bị oan không? Đáp: Không, Ủy ban xác nhận quyết định đuổi Huijsen chính xác.
After 90 minutes of the Madrid derby, no one remembers the score. They only remember three names: Kang-in Lee, Cuti Romero and Jude Bellingham. And they remember one statistic: three. Three serious errors by referee Miguel Ángel Ortiz Arias, all in Atlético Madrid's favour, confirmed by Spain's Referees' Technical Committee. Two errors were corrected by VAR. One was completely ignored. AS obtained the committee's internal assessment and published it immediately after the final whistle. "Among thousands of numbers, the truth never needs to shout." But that night, the truth did not need to shout - it screamed from every screen, every newspaper, every radio debate in Madrid.
The Madrid derby is a life-and-death battle between two clubs from the same city. For Atlético and Real Madrid, this fixture matters more than three points because it defines status in the hearts of supporters and creates a psychological turning point for the whole season. In the current campaign, with both clubs chasing the La Liga title, the weight of every referee decision grows even larger. One mistake can change everything, and three mistakes in a single match is a cardinal sin - for the referee, and for the VAR system itself, designed precisely to prevent such errors.
The Referees' Technical Committee (CTA) is the body responsible for overseeing referee standards in Spain, with the power to evaluate, grade and propose sanctions. It is extremely rare for the CTA to react after one match. Even more tellingly, they did not publish the assessment officially; it was "leaked" through AS. This approach increases the weight of the information: if it were official, Madridistas would treat it as hard evidence; if it is a leak, both sides can exploit it. Real Madrid sees it as an admission by the authorities. Atlético sees it as part of a media conspiracy against them. Meanwhile, the truth lies in the specific incidents, and those incidents can all be verified. Based on my decades of experience following Spanish football, I can say this: rarely has VAR lost control in a derby to such an extent. The most striking point is that two of the three errors did not come from deliberate bias, but from inconsistency in how VAR operates - a system born to reduce mistakes, yet that night it produced more questions than answers.
Let us start with the most serious incident. In the second half, Kang-in Lee lunged in with his studs, from behind, catching Federico Valverde on the Achilles tendon. Under IFAB laws, this is serious foul play - an offence that must be punished with a straight red card. Referee Ortiz Arias stood less than ten metres away, with an unobstructed view, but he only awarded a direct free kick. No yellow card. No red card. VAR also stayed silent. This is the incident that raises the biggest question about VAR protocol. In two other situations, VAR intervened very quickly. So why did the VAR team fail to act here? Two possibilities: either they judged it not a "clear and obvious" error requiring intervention, or they simply missed it. A third possibility - deliberate inaction - is too serious to allege without evidence. But whatever the reason, VAR's silence in the face of a challenge that endangered a player's safety is a severe systemic failure.
The second incident came shortly after. Cuti Romero fouled Jude Bellingham inside Atlético's penalty area. According to the committee's assessment, Romero pulled Bellingham down just as the England forward was about to go one-on-one with the goalkeeper - a situation that could be classified as DOGSO (denying an obvious goal-scoring opportunity), an indirect red-card offence. VAR intervened, but only to confirm there was no penalty. Romero was not sent off. Why? If it was DOGSO, a red card had to be shown even without a penalty. VAR's half-measure made the situation more ambiguous than ever. The system seemed to admit an error but lacked the courage to fix it completely. That is the most dangerous kind of tolerance in modern football: a wrong decision half-corrected, turning into a completely different wrong decision.
The third incident was a different kind of mistake. Bellingham - the same player who had just been fouled - received a yellow card for an offence he did not commit. The referee confused the players. VAR acted quickly, rescinded the yellow card and showed it to the correct player. This proves VAR works perfectly when the error is "mistaken identity" - a mechanical, easily identifiable error. But when faced with incidents requiring subjective judgment, such as the severity of a challenge or the risk of injury, the system goes silent. This is VAR's blind spot: it is effective with measurable errors, but timid with interpretive ones. A system half-active, half-asleep. And when a system falls asleep, it is not harmless - it enables injustice.
Finally, there is the incident in which Dean Huijsen was sent off for holding Giuliano Simeone in the penalty area. The committee confirmed this decision was fully correct. This detail is crucial because it breaks the narrative that "the referee always favoured Atlético". Huijsen was sent off, but Real Madrid suffered in three other situations. The picture is not one-dimensional. And this complexity is precisely what makes the story so toxic: when there is no clear explanatory model, everyone creates their own. In Spanish social media debates, the model chosen is almost always "the referee was biased". In reality, the problem may simply be procedural incompetence. But incompetence, repeated over and over, becomes a form of bias.
Remarkably, throughout the entire assessment, not a single technical statistic - xG, possession share, pass count - was mentioned. This shows how the refereeing narrative dominated to the point of pushing the entire tactical context of the derby out of the frame. A top-class match between two of Spain's leading clubs was reduced to three wrong decisions. That is both sad and revealing: modern football is being ruled by cards and whistles, not by passes and goals.
Public pressure is now weighing heavily on referee Ortiz Arias. In La Liga's history, referees who make serious errors in major derbies are often demoted to the second division or temporarily removed from high-profile matches. If the Committee officially sanctions him, that would be a strong signal that the system can still correct itself. But if it does not, the question of VAR transparency will remain a crack running through Spanish football. Real Madrid fans had a sleepless night. They saw in those three incidents a familiar script: their team treated unfairly. But Atlético fans also have reason to be angry: they have been labelled as "aided by the referee", which diminishes their own team's achievement. In a derby where the referee becomes the centre of attention, nobody truly wins.
The crowd is screaming that the referee favoured Atlético. But as someone who follows data, I see a deeper and more frightening problem: the inconsistency within VAR itself. If VAR can intervene in twenty seconds to fix a mistaken-identity yellow card for Bellingham, why can it not spend sixty seconds reviewing Kang-in Lee's challenge? If VAR determined that Romero fouled Bellingham, why did it not apply the DOGSO rule fully? "Sensationalist media sell legends. I sell a map of the truth." The map of truth here shows: referee Ortiz Arias may not be biased. He may simply be inconsistent, lacking courage in interpretive decisions. But the end result is the same: three errors, all in one direction. In football, intention matters less than data. The referee's intention is unmeasurable. Data shows three errors, three disadvantages for Real Madrid. "No need to look at the lineup. Data already said who would lose three months ago." But that night, data only showed who was treated unfairly, and who was benefiting from that injustice.
If the Referees' Committee truly wants to calm the storm, they need to do one thing: release the audio recordings of the conversations between the referee and the VAR team regarding the Kang-in Lee incident. One release would answer every question. But if they choose silence, the storm will not stop at one derby. It will spread across La Liga, eroding fans' trust in the fairness of the competition. "When the stadium falls silent, the true heartbeat of the match lies in the charts, not in the cheers." And the chart that night said one thing: Spanish football is bleeding trust. Will La Liga dare to look straight at the VAR screen and say the system is working for football - or is it just working for itself?



Cầu thủ liên quan
Bài đề xuất
Chivas remains the backbone of Mexico's national team in Rafa Márquez's first squad list2026-09-18
Indonesia targets FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026 championship: Ambition with foundation or excessive pressure?2026-09-07
Harry Maguire and the Number 66: When the Three Lions No Longer Need an Aerial Centre-Back2026-09-26
Red Bull and Racing Bulls rotate internal seats: Hadjar out, Lawson in, Tsunoda remains2026-09-08
'Football' mislabel on a stock market report: A verification lesson for sports journalism2026-09-08
Adzic's Goal Against Juventus: When a Loan Gift Bites Its Owner2026-09-14
Bài đề xuất
FC Utrecht concede nine goals in two games: Anthony Correia's problem is not his back line2026-09-22
Serie A Matchday 8 Referee Appointments: What the List Reveals Beyond the Fixtures2026-10-22
Đình Bắc and the Glass of Beer: The Fragile Line Between 'Jewel' and the Shadow of the Past2026-09-04
Vinicius's four-match ban is a squad-depth stress test, not a form crisis2026-10-23
Al-Ahli welcome Ivan Toney back before Al-Khaleej: selection risk and injury puzzle2026-10-22
Slow Counter-Attacks: The Unsolved Puzzle of Vietnam National Team Under Coach Kim Sang-sik2026-09-03
JJ Gabriel and the Article 19 Door: When a Passport Decides a 15-Year-Old's Future2026-09-19
